Connect with us


Analysis: Dissecting Penguins’ Domi Offer & Lineup Decisions



Max Domi Twitter Avatar

Late Friday night, Pittsburgh Hockey Now reported some in the Penguins organization were surprised they didn’t acquire Arizona Coyotes forward Max Domi, who was instead traded to the Montreal Canadiens for Alex Galchenyuk. The Penguins are believed to have offered Conor Sheary or Bryan Rust, packaged with winger Dominic Simon.

What should fans make of the offer and deal?

Arizona did very well to land a player of Galchenyuk’s pedigree for Domi. The Canadiens offer was superior to the Penguins believed offer, especially based on Arizona’s needs. Galchenyuk was drafted third overall by the Canadiens in 2012. However, he was never the savior they needed. Coaches Michael Therrien and Claude Julien bounced him from wing to center and back, hoping to find his fit but he never arrived.

Despite the turmoil, Galchenyuk, 24, posted more than 50 points in two of the last three years. Last season, he had 19 markers and 32 assists, for a respectable 51 points.

Perhaps Coyotes head coach Rick Tocchet will mesh with Galchenyuk and lead him to be the center everyone believes he is capable. Montreal’s player development has not been successful under GM Marc Bergevin. A list of players including Charles Hudon, Sven Andrighetto and most recently Jonathan Drouin, have underperformed their potential.

For Domi, 23, things had soured in Arizona. Perpetual losing, tepid fan support, an undermanned team and an intense head coach isn’t the best combination. As Tocchet told Pittsburgh Hockey Now last winter, it took a while for the players to buy-in. In his January interview with PHN, Tocchet expressed optimism in his team’s growth but was occasionally frustrated by their progress. Read that story here.

Domi’s statistical slide through that situation isn’t uncommon for a young player.

Domi also suffered through the last couple years of head coach Dave Tippet, in Arizona. Tippet pulled the reigns tightly on his young team, emphasizing defense often at the expense of an aggressive game. As we have seen from other players escaping similar situations across the NHL (*ahem, Ottawa), it can be tough to de-program after becoming a plumber (plumber = hockey term to describe blue-collar grinders).

Sheary or Rust?

Both Sheary and Rust are 26-years-old. We have probably seen the best from each, and we have certainly seen better from Sheary than his 2017-18 season.

If the Penguins did put Rust on the table, it adds a new name to the list. Several teams looking to get faster or grittier would be wise to make that call to Penguins general manager Jim Rutherford. Rust is a versatile player with top-shelf speed, tenacity, big-game chops, and sprinkles in enough offense to be a stopgap top-six winger from either side.

Sheary is an interesting asset. One year ago, he posted 53 points in just 61 games. Based on analytics, he elevated Sidney Crosby’s statistics and was a useful cog in the offensive machine. However, Sheary struggled in the playoffs and even earned a couple healthy scratches.

Montreal came strong to the table for Domi. The Penguins simply couldn’t match that offer. The price tag is now set. The Penguins can deal Sheary or Rust, but their return is looking less promising than their potential value next season.

What if Domi Were a Penguin?

Domi would have presented interesting lineup decisions for the Penguins. Domi plays with abandon but is a play-maker, more than a goal scorer, and that combination

Would they have slotted Domi as the third line center and attempted to deal Derick Brassard?

Would they have cut bait with Riley Sheahan, who is an RFA?

Would Domi have taken Jake Guentzel’s spot on Sidney Crosby’s left wing to add more goals to Crosby’s tally?

A Domi-Brassard combination seems very unlikely given both players’ preference to pass before shooting. And given Guentzel’s late-season heroics, again, beside Crosby, that spot seems to be taken. So that leaves us with two likely scenarios: The Penguins would pair Domi and Sheahan on the fourth line, or the Penguins were also prepared to move Brassard.


The bet from this corner is Brassard would have been moved had the Penguins acquired Domi. Imagine, a young playmaker with Phil Kessel. We’ve seen that movie before, and it had a big box office score. To acquire Domi for fourth line duty doesn’t seem to make sense, even if he plays with a more physical edge than Sheary.

We are left to wonder what the Penguins had in mind. Arizona took a good deal with Montreal and both players are likely better off. But the Penguins thinking on the deal could be clues to general manager Jim Rutherford’s thinking, as the Penguins face their first off-season since 2015 without a Stanley Cup.

Subscribe to PHN+

Pittsburgh Hockey Now Editor-in-Chief, formerly 93.7 The Fan, Sportsnet Hockey Tonight, NHL Home Ice. Catch Dan tweeting @theDanKingerski and the official @pghhockeynow account.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
4 years ago

I really like 43 effort and skill but he too small and plays a light game. The team already has 81 who plays the same way but obviously is much better offensively than 43. Rust plays with grit and a sandpaper approach. The Pens need more players like him along with his speed. Kunitz is a good example of that type of player also. 81, 43, 58, 59. 2 are smaller type players. Maybe the team needs a lil more size overall. 59 iwill hit and is tough. But 59 gets rocked a lot and sooner or later those hits… Read more »

4 years ago

Domni to Peenguins would have big deal but not Even Up For Kessel

The offer by Pens. Was Not enough Very poor Rust and Shery are 4th Line Guys

It’s playing with superstars Crosby and Mulkin that makes look better.


Jeff Houston
Jeff Houston
4 years ago
Reply to  Joe

I agree with u and think they could have given more. But also think that MTL gave up too much!!
I had the trade 2-ways;
Sheary / Ruhwedel / 19′-1st rdr
Domi / A. Hill (good goalie prospect) and ARZ 18′-3rd rdr

OR – I had;
Rust / Simon / 19′- 1st rdr
Domi / A. Hill / ARZ 18′-3rd rdr

Rich Filardi
Rich Filardi
4 years ago

Either of those guys are not going to net what change this teams needs alone, so I have to think they are going to be paired with another player of value to get something that this team determines a better overall asset to success.

Join PHN Extra!

Join PHN+ today for exclusive content from Dan, Dave and Shelly plus a completely Google ad-free experience.


Or enter your email below to sign-up for our mailing list.

Thank you!

Something went wrong.

No thanks. I don't want.