Connect with us


Dan’s Daily: Penguins Rutherford Outbid Six Teams for Kapanen



Pittsburgh Penguins trade; GM Jim Rutherford NHL trade rumors
Pittsburgh Penguins GM Jim Rutherford press conference, 2019.

The fishbowl in Toronto doesn’t hold many secrets. After the Pittsburgh Penguins trade for Kasperi Kapanen, our friends in Toronto kept digging. The results were shocking and may make you question Penguins GM Jim Rutherford. Also, in the links below, the NHL held a moment of reflection after the police shooting in Kenosha, WI. The Tampa Bay Lightning earned a 2-1 series, lead, as the Colorado Avalanche and Philadelphia Flyers both avoided going down 3-0.

First, the Penguins.

For our subscribers, the Kapanen – Penguins trade really hurt the Penguins’ ability to re-tool. We explain in detail (PHN+)

Pittsburgh Penguins GM Jim Rutherford outbid six teams for Kapanen, according to TSN’s Pierre LeBrun. Josh Gold-Smith of the Score recaps the details (The Score)

The Chicago Blackhawks refused to give up the 17th overall pick for Kapanen, and the Carolina Hurricanes refused to part with the 13th overall pick.

In other words, the Penguins were the ONLY team willing to give that first-rounder for Kapanen. If the Penguins were on the verge of being great, and this deal shoved them in that direction, it would be hard to argue. However, that is not the case.

Other teams appropriately judged their position. Rutherford did not.

As PHN noted in our instant analysis, the Penguins overpaid. We detailed the overpay, but now we know just how badly. As a writer and broadcaster, I’ve seldomly criticized Rutherford, but this overpay also ties the Penguins’ hands in their re-tooling effort. Kapanen isn’t a bad acquisition, but the Penguins paid a bad price; a price which other teams desperate for the same help refused.

Colorado and Dallas held a moment of reflection before Game 3 on Wednesday night after an unarmed black man, Jacob Blake, was shot by police in Kenosha, WI (Sportsnet)

After a deep google search, I finally found the videos, including the second angle. Here’s the story (ABC 7)

Evander Kane and Matt Dumba, who co-founded the Hockey Diversity Alliance, spoke out against the NHL’s response (Yahoo Sports)

National Hockey Now

Tampa Bay essentially ran over Boston in Game 3. Rookie Dan Vladar started in goal for Boston and Tampa hung a 7 on him. Five takeaways from the beatdown (Boston Hockey Now)

Colorado looked a bit like…Colorado on Wednesday night. They beat Dallas to save their season and avoid a 3-0 hole. Dater dishes the grades (Colorado Hockey Now)

It’s an absolute crazy world we live in. Nuts, actually. San Jose Sharks forward Logan Couture was sucker punched for mentioning Donald Trump (San Jose Hockey Now)

John Cleese, of Monty Python brilliance perhaps summed it up best 30 years ago…

Subscribe to PHN+
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
1 year ago

Dan, I really appreciate your candor regarding GMJR’s latest move. I find most of his moves since beating the Preds fall into the poor to mediocre range. Lots of chasing “meh” deals with more “meh” deals. Keep up the excellent work. Thanks

1 year ago

Rutherford beat out a lot of teams for Brassard too. Kapanen isn’t Brassard but the same all too anxious buyers mentality is the same. Hope Jim wants my house when it’s on the market! Dan you are one of the very few to be analytical and critical. Even Madden is couching his criticism in ‘ if he believes the window is still there….” And the homer shills who pushed for Conor ‘Howdy Doody’ Sheary are on the air defending Jim. Funny , Steigerwald who pushed for Sheary said on Maddens show ” the book is still out on Kahun”. Wish… Read more »

1 year ago
Reply to  Katz

Should read ‘way too easy’Not BBC east ugh auto correct

1 year ago
Reply to  Katz

Brassard is a center
Kapanen a winger
Brassard a marshmallow
Kapanen forechecks presents another SH off PK.
I’ll take Kap
Fans are mostly stupid in these things wanting to trade Malkin, Letang, and Crosby.

1 year ago

he’s like a day trader with no plan

1 year ago

not gonna judge until the puck drops next season. soon enough we’ll be getting 1st round picks back once we trade letang and malkin in a few years. crosby will be the only one who retires as a pengiun.

Join PHN Extra!

Join PHN+ today for exclusive content from Dan, Dave and Shelly plus a completely Google ad-free experience.


Or enter your email below to sign-up for our mailing list.

Thank you!

Something went wrong.

No thanks. I don't want.