Penguins Mythbusters: Jack Johnson & Daniel Sprong | Pittsburgh Hockey Now
Connect with us


Penguins Mythbusters: Jack Johnson & Daniel Sprong



Penguins Jack Johnson trade talk
WASHINGTON, DC - NOVEMBER 07: Pittsburgh Penguins defenseman Jack Johnson (73) hits Washington Capitals defenseman Michal Kempny (6) in the first period on November 7, 2018, at the Capital One Arena in Washington, D.C. (Photo by Mark Goldman/Icon Sportswire)

Losing breeds a lot of theories, second-guessing and demands. We all get smarter. The team gets dumber. Lately, the Pittsburgh Penguins experienced far too much losing and more than a few opinions became fact as the social media voices, fans, and some media collided to confirm each other. Opinions about Jack Johnson and Daniel Sprong top the list of frequently pushed views which have only become stronger.

Trigger warning–this won’t be a column which supports popular emotions. It won’t be to inflame but to balance. And maybe slow down the runaway train of unwarranted player bashing, or praising.

Myth #1: Jack Johnson Sucks!

Penguins fans have not only pinned team failures on Johnson, but they’ve also blamed him for mistakes of others, too. Penguins give up a goal while Johnson is on the ice? Johnson’s fault. Other team gets sustained offensive pressure? Johnson’s fault. The other four players or opponents? Don’t matter.

Mike Sullivan has rarely if ever–unprompted– gone out of his way to defend his players from specific fan criticism. He did so for Johnson after Johnson was on the ice for five goals against earlier this season. For this and numerous other reasons such as ice time, situational placement, and pairing assignment, count the coaches in Johnson’s corner.

Now, here’s where it gets deep. Jack Johnson is not only a solid NHL defender, but he excels in his own zone. Things which don’t show up on the stat sheet, such as boxing out his man in front of the net, pinning forwards to the wall, and winning physical battles. Even during the losing streak, Johnson kept opponents away from the net.

Rewatch the Columbus win. Johnson was a textbook defender as he pushed around Brandon Dubinsky and Josh Anderson. Such occurrences aren’t infrequent. Johnson also has 60 hits in 22 games and rarely gets beaten by his man.

This is a prime example–Johnson quickly adjusted to a forward’s turnover, kept the crease clear, allowed the goalie to see the shot and prevented traffic. Those are all good things which are most evident when they’re not present. LIke an offensive line only gets screen time when something bad happens, Johnson is in a similar situation.

And the important statistic–Scoring chances–is dead even in the last 10 games, with 66 chances for and against. One odd note, as Johnson’s scoring chances were upside down, his Corsi rating was right side up, and when his Corsi was on the positive side of 50 percent, his scoring chances were below water. I very likely explanation is when teams take the advantage on the Penguins, Johnson can protect zone and absorb shots but not chances–that’s the strength of Jack Johnson.


#2 Daniel Sprong Should Play with Sid!

If only Mike Sullivan didn’t hate Daniel Sprong, he would be in the Penguins top-9, playing with good players and he would be scoring. Additional subsets include, “You have to find out what he can do,” “Other players make mistakes but don’t get benched,” “Other players suck, at least Sprong might score,” and the most egregious, “Dominik Simon is terrible! The coaches favor him over Sprong.”

RedBeard's Pittsburgh

There’s a lot to unpack with the Sprong beliefs. Let’s start with this: Sprong doesn’t have to score on the fourth line to get a promotion. He simply has to prove proficiency in the NHL game.

So many of the things Sprong doesn’t do, is struggling to do, or is learning to do are not obvious to most. Puck support is a huge one. The Penguins fourth line Corsi and scoring chances spiked when the Penguins recalled Zach Aston-Reese and scratched Sprong because the line was able to gain possession and play with the puck. Sprong’s puck support is a still a mess.

“Other players make mistakes!”

They do, but other players can be counted on to make the right play, be in the right spot and do the right things. So when they don’t, it is an obvious mistake. Sprong is still learning almost everything and on any given shift can (and often does) make several mistakes.

Sprong’s play away from the puck is another big one which hurts possession and chances. Matt Cullen took a lot of heat from ardent Sprong believers, but Cullen played very well with Riley Sheahan and Patric Hornqvist (until the coaches overused him), and very well with Garrett Wilson and Aston-Reese.

So, the direct comparison is damning. Now, imagine a lack of puck support, play away from the puck and defensive positioning with Sidney Crosby’s line and against the opponent’s top line. What could it hurt? Not only would such a line combo be detrimental to Crosby, but it would also be harmful to the team.

Jake DeBrusk’s one-timer was a stoppable shot but note Sprong abdicating his primary coverage which allowed a much better opportunity.

The team began training camp and preseason with the Sprong-Crosby combination and with Dominik Simon who plays a smart, fast game. Simon passed his test. Sprong is still studying. It’s not the coaches holding him back. They know full well what he can do–for better and worse–even as many choose to believe he can be the same scorer he was in the AHL last season.

There are a lot of players who score points in the AHL but not the NHL. Garrett Wilson is a point-per-game player in the AHL this season. It’s a much different league.

Sprong does not have to be perfect, but he has to attain the basic feel of the game. When he does, his scoring chances will appear. The Penguins puck possession on his line will appear, and everyone will know it’s time to elevate Sprong.

The Penguins coaches are doing their best to develop Sprong in the NHL and win hockey games, too. The team isn’t currently in a position to water seeds which don’t bear fruit. It’s not fair to Sprong to be in such a position, trying to take a graduate course before mastering professional hockey 101 but that’s the position all find themselves.




Subscribe to PHN+

Pittsburgh Hockey Now owner, formerly 93.7 The Fan, Sportsnet Hockey Tonight. Catch Dan tweeting @theDanKingerski and the official @pghhockeynow account.



  1. gerald gilbert

    November 26, 2018 at 11:23 am

    I agree with everything you wrote. Johnson had a huge learning curve going from teams that want to play big to a team that wants to play fast. I think he can do it but it will take time. Time on the other hand is what has been taken from Sprong. Its all water under the bridge now. He will have a harder time reaching his peak. He has the skill he just needs to think the game better. That will come with playing time but that’s the catch! Like you said with the struggles the Pens have faced they can’t afford him that time now.

  2. kerrdog2111

    November 26, 2018 at 8:48 pm

    I totally agree with you on Johnson but Sprong not so much ( big surprise right?). Johnson has been, as far as I am concerned pretty solid especially here lately. I think playing him with the Big Rig on the third pairing has taken some pressure off him and I love the way he throws his weight around. Now Sprong has been miss handled from day one so this is not strictly Sullys doing. They should have never burned a year but they did, so we are where we are with him now. Would it be nice to send him down and let him play? Sure it would, but even if he could go down to the AHL, and did well down there Sully wouldn’t call him up. Let’s call a spade a spade, Sully does not like the kid period! He has eroded this kids confidence to the point where Sprong spends most of his time on the ice staring at the bench with the ” am I doing this right face”. Now Sprong played better last game setting up Shea with a couple of golden chances and did some decent backchecking. What did that get him? He was stapled to the bench yet again. So you say he doesn’t have to score to change his lot, I agree he doesn’t cause his lot isn’t going to change even if he scores. ZAR made the same mistake on CBJ’s first goal and Sully didn’t bat an eye, well besides saying “that was your guy Reese”. The good news is that Sprongs stats compare pretty closely to Kasperi Kapanen. If you look at Kaps stats over his first 3 years he played 55 games had 10 points and was on the wrong side of the +- at -6. Over the last 3 (playing) years, Sprong has played 42 games has 9 points and is also on the wrong side of the +- at -6. Pretty darn close right. Now Kap has taken off this year but he has been playing with better players, that’s not going to happen for Sprong at least not this year, not on this team. I will say that I would rather have Sully not play Sprong if he is not going to use him. I like Sprongs potential talent but I would rather not have Sully overtaxing the top two lines to cover for Sprong. Above all, I am a Pens fan and I want them to win, and I don’t want overtired guys come April.

  3. RSteep

    November 27, 2018 at 10:40 am

    I respectfully disagree with Dan about Sprong. It’s not that I think he should play with Sid, he shouldn’t. But he should get a few shifts with Malkin. Sprong keeps getting compared to Neal, yet Sully refuses to use him in a similar manner. Neal has never been strong defensively, but he has a killer a shot and worked very well with Geno. Sure Kessel and Geno has been working pretty good this year, but occasionally the shine wears off and Sully puts Hornqvist with Geno. I love Horny, but he just kills Geno’s game. Hornqvist then gets injured and instead of trying something that may work, Sully goes right back to Kessel. It’s not a bad thing, but this team has won cups by having 3 scoring lines. Brassard needs some talent on his wing and Kessel should be that guy. Malkin and Sprong have basically played one shift together all year and Geno scored from a beauty pass by Sprong. Why not give him a few more shots. Sprong is never going to be a two way forward, yet Sully is trying to force him to be. No wonder the kid is struggling. A square peg does not fit into a round hole.

    Currently I would run with:
    Jake – Sid – Simon
    Pearson – Geno – Sprong
    Rust – Brassard – Kessel
    Wilson – Sheahan – ZAR

    When Horny is healthy, play him with Sid, Simon on the left with Brassard, ZAR on the left with Sheahan and Rust on the 4th RW.

    With this line-up you are going to get people complaining that Kessel or Rust aren’t getting enough playing time. However I would essentially roll my lines with Line 1 and 2 basically getting equal time and line 3 just barely above line 4. Have Sheahan, Rust, ZAR and either Simon or Pearson on the PK.

    But what do I know.

    • Dan Kingerski

      November 27, 2018 at 3:13 pm

      To posit such, I’ll refer to the line—To be promoted, Sprong doesn’t need to score, but he needs to show a mastery of the basics of professional hockey. There has been no tangible proof of such or of NHL offensive might–only hope and wishes. I can’t stress enough how rough his game is and to push for top-6 time is to ignore that basic barrier. His game wouldn’t flourish, it would limit his talented linemates.

Make your voice heard

%d bloggers like this:

Join PHN Extra!

Join PHN+ today for exclusive content from Dan and Shelly plus a completely Google ad-free experience.


Or enter your email below to sign-up for our mailing list.

Thank you!

Something went wrong.

No thanks. I don't want.

Send this to a friend