Pens Give It Away in 6: Why the Regular Season Matters
Connect with us


Pens Give It Away in 6: Why the Regular Season Matters



It seems too fitting. In a series decided by Pittsburgh Penguins gaffes, the biggest gaffes by defenseman Kris Letang, it was again a mistake by Letang which rolled the red carpet for Washington Capitals forward Evgeny Kuznetsov on the overtime game-winning breakaway. The Capitals also burned Letang for a pair of goals in the third period of Game 5.

It’s over. The Penguins have no one else to blame but themselves. No one. The Penguins couldn’t beat the Capitals who played without Tom Wilson and Nicklas Backstrom. The only team the Penguins could beat were themselves.

They held a third period lead over the Capitals four times in the first five games. They won just two.

And this is why the regular season matters.

While other teams escalated their game, honed strategies and, most importantly, formed good habits over the past six months, the Penguins blew off the regular season. They had won two consecutive Stanley Cups. Surely they could turn it on when necessary. No worries.

“They’ll be fine,” said fans.

“We’ll be fine,” said the team.

They weren’t fine. In Round 2, the Penguins played with playoff intensity but an October structure. Never were they consistent. In the playoffs, never did they play consecutive well-executed games. The Penguins flailed about like an unprepared boxer who tried to rely on veteran skills to beat a hungry opponent.

Just like the Tampa Bay Lightning, who last year lumbered through the regular season and missed the playoffs, the Penguins tried to skip ahead to the end of the book.

RedBeard's Pittsburgh

This is why Mike Sullivan gritted his teeth and went to the whip, at mid-season. The writing was on the wall. And not even the acquisition of the top trade target Derick Brassard could pull it all together.

On Monday night, long before the final sentence was written, the goats and heroes lined up. With their goal within reach, the Capitals had energy and hunger in the third period and into overtime.

Before the Penguins allowed yet another odd-man rush, Phil Kessel continued to mishandle the puck. NBCSN announcers marveled at Letang and Brian Dumoulin’s poor communication and positioning, while Capitals grinders Lars Eller, Alex Chaisson, and Brett Connolly had big chances.

Braden Holtby made saves, and Matt Murray rebounded from a soft goal to make a handful of great saves. It came down to who wanted it more and who would make a key mistake. The Capitals didn’t over-commit or gamble, despite having momentum late in the game.

In fact, that was the Capitals strategy for most of Game 6. Without Wilson (suspension) and Backstrom (injury), they chose to forgo offense in exchange for limiting the Penguins offense. The strategy was pitch perfect. The Capitals restricted the Penguins rush by taking every inch of space in the neutral zone and attacking the Penguins puck carriers.

The Capitals executed flawlessly. Like their playoff lives depended on it.

The Capitals defensive strategy essentially relied on Penguins mistakes. And they forced many. Even Sidney Crosby turned the puck over three times in the first period, including a gift to Kuznetsov in front of the Penguins net. Perhaps Crosby turned it over on the Kuznetsov winner, too.

Penguins head coach Mike Sullivan shuffled his lines in the second period, and the Penguins had a pulse. They pushed the Capitals throughout the second period, but could not sustain it.

Three straight Stanley Cups is a near impossible feat. In the salary-cap era, it could be a long, long time before another team even repeats let alone chases three. And that is what makes the Penguins loss so significant.

They could have won the series. They should have won the series. Had the Penguins played well, it would have been possible to beat the Tampa Bay Lightning and any team in the Western Conference. They didn’t have to be hungrier than the Capitals, they merely had to limit mistakes.

The championship window is far from shut. The Penguins are still and will be very good for several more years. And that’s why the next regular season, which begins in October, will matter.

Subscribe to PHN Extra

Pittsburgh Hockey Now owner, formerly 93.7 The Fan, Sportsnet Hockey Tonight. Catch Dan tweeting @theDanKingerski and the official @pghhockeynow account.



  1. Matt Luda

    May 8, 2018 at 1:30 am

    Pathetic way to finish the season. Couldn’t beat a team that was without three of its top nine forwards. In a must-win situation. At home, no less.

    Not surprised, though. I witnessed the 10-1 embarrassment in Chicago, which they treated like an exhibition game. Where was the fire? Instead, dll we heard about was how tired the players were. Sully never could get through to them. Many of the mistakes we saw in Game 6 were the ones they made seven months ago.

    I’ll always remember the 2018 season as a huge disappointment, a squandered opportunity of a lifetime.

  2. John

    May 8, 2018 at 3:20 am

    The Penguins squandered the 3-peat in the Game 6 OT loss to the Capitals. I think this was a weaker Capital team than years past. Great article Dan on the PENS mistakes. They just didn’t have the fire to finish off the Capitals. I don’t know why…Maybe, it was the accumulation of injuries and intense games and playoffs over 3 Stanley Cup runs. Happens to the best teams including the Islanders & Oilers runs. It would have been exciting Game 7. We can only wonder now what would have happened. Congrats to Kessel, Letang, Malkin, Sid & Company on a perfect 100 point season. I am worried about all the high draft picks and young talent that was traded away. The PENS could get old in a hurry. My guess they will have to shed some salary. A couple of those 4+ million $ contracts. I’m spoiled May had always been filled with playoff hockey the last few years.

  3. Ricardo58

    May 8, 2018 at 6:37 am

    Thanks for the excellent article!
    I hope the GM and Sullivan have an honest assessment of the team even if they provide cliche responses to the shortcomings of the tram. If not the Pens will become the recent edition of the Chicago Blackhawks.
    Remember the comment by either the GM or HC when asked about the 3rd line center after Bonino departed and the reply was the team still had 87 and 71. Elite players but not enough still as the Caps just demonstrated. The supporting cast wasn’t as strong this season.

  4. Robert

    May 8, 2018 at 8:14 am

    I think Sullivan said after the game something to the effect of you learn more from your defeats than you do from your victories. Hopefully the ideas in your article are what they learn. They seemed blasé and arrogant early in the season. Adding Brassard and losing Reaves and Cole forced new people to learn each others’ tendencies late in the season. They never seemed to gel. Here’s hoping they get some rest, heal up, and that the taste of losing gets them fired up for next season. This is a core that has won back-to-back cups and 3 in total. They have more in them.

  5. Tony Mo

    May 8, 2018 at 4:04 pm

    Well written and thoughtful, Dan. Thanks

    • Dan Kingerski

      May 10, 2018 at 11:33 am

      Welcome. Thank you for the clicks and twitter responses.

Make your voice heard

%d bloggers like this:

Join PHN Extra!

Join PHN Extra today for exclusive content from Dan and Shelly plus a completely Google ad-free experience.

PHN Extra

Or enter your email below to sign-up for our mailing list.

Thank you!

Something went wrong.

No thanks. I don't want.

Send this to a friend