TSN Button: Penguins Blame Kessel, Extremely Attractive Trade Option | Pittsburgh Hockey Now
Connect with us


TSN Button: Penguins Blame Kessel, Extremely Attractive Trade Option



In the preceding weeks and days, TSN Insiders Bob McKenzie and Pierre LeBrun have confirmed that Phil Kessel will most likely be traded this summer. Following the first official Kessel trade rumors this week, TSN’s held a panel discussion to explore Kessel’s value and analyst Craig Button sang sweet music to Penguins and Kessel fans ears.

Button was entirely bullish on Kessel’s value.

“Extreme attractive. He’s a point per game player who has shown no signs of decline in his game,” Button said. “It’s so interesting to think–OK, it gets to the point we start maligning Phil Kessel again.”

Kessel scored 82 points in 82 games this season, including 27 goals. For nine straight seasons, Kessel has played every game, too. The enigmatic winger has reportedly clashed with Penguins coaches. Button did not leave any doubt on which side of the debate he falls.

“The Pittsburgh Penguins have serious cap issues. So now they look at Phil Kessel. Blame Phil Kessel for their woes,” Button barked. “Two Stanley Cups, a point per game player. A $6.8 million cap hit.”

“I’ll tell you what, you want scoring, you want consistency, I want Phil Kessel.”

Button just gained thousands of new Penguins followers. Unfortunately, the online video is not available in the U.S., but Canadian readers may watch the video here. Button wasn’t done firing away in defense of Kessel.

“Take advantage of the problems Pittsburgh has with the salary cap and get this guy because he will help you and produce points.”

RedBeard's Pittsburgh

Kessel has 174 points over the past two seasons which makes him one of the leading scorers in the NHL over that time. A minus-19 rating and other game deficiencies combined with locker room friction and the Penguins embarrassing Round One loss prompted Penguins GM Jim Rutherford to consider big changes to the Penguins

Former NHL player and TSN analyst Dave Poulin was also the other half of the panel discussion. He offered a slightly different though Kessel positive take, too.

“I totally agree with all of the skills, but I think Phil Kessel is an acquired taste and its run its course in Pittsburgh,” Poulin conceded. “The numbers are actually remarkable. His highest point years are actually his last two years with 92 and 82 points. He’s won two Stanley Cups with 22 and 23 points in the Cup years.”

As a former NHL player, Poulin did provide more insight into the situation.

“He’s answered everything on the ice. From a personal standpoint, maybe a motivational standpoint, for him–he’s run his course,” Poulin continued. “He’s a star player with star talent who can’t be your star player. He’s a complimentary star to superstars.”

“The abilities are there, no question. It has to be the right fit.”

PHN’s Dan Kingerski offered a different take on the Kessel trade discussion Friday and attempted to explain the rumored low return for Kessel. 

Thus far this offseason, the Penguins only move has been to sign depth defenseman Chad Ruhwedel to a two-year $1.3 million contract, though Jim Rutherford has also refused to confirm Evgeni Malkin will be a part of next year’s team and head coach Mike Sullivan seemed to single out Kessel’s deficiencies when he explained what his team needed to improve for next season.

Regardless of the Penguins feelings, the TSN panel and especially Button made his feelings known, too.

Subscribe to PHN+


  1. Pingback: TSN Button: Penguins Blame Kessel, Extremely Attractive Trade Option - Pittsburgh Hockey Now - NHL Rumor Mill

  2. RobertU

    May 25, 2019 at 10:27 am

    I’m guessing he hasn’t watched him play, if his logic boils down to “he’s a point per game player.” Unfortunately, he’s also a 1.23 pts against per game player. Take out power play, and where are his #s? Add in all the negative intangibles, character issues, and 3x burnout with 3 different teams…

    • acpappas

      May 25, 2019 at 1:13 pm

      How many even strength goals did he have in the final 30 or so games of the regular season? The guy scores, but having Crosby and Malkin makes it a lot easier than say what would be around him in Arizona or Minnesota. Let’s see him play a year in one of those cities and see if he is still a point-a-game player

    • David

      May 30, 2019 at 6:29 pm

      Ive said that from the start. He hasn’t missed a game in 9 years? Check out his stats for hits and shot blocks. Almost non-existent. Even elite players like Crosby have tons more. That is why he never gets hurt. How many goals has that cost the Pens offense, let alone defense? There is no stat for goals your own team did not score because of your play. His -19 is a clue. I watch every Pens game. Both he and Malkin played horrible this year — at times embarrassing. Thank him for his contributions to the 2 Cups and get what you can. But its time.

  3. Matt Luda

    May 25, 2019 at 1:47 pm

    GMJR can’t half-ass it this summer. He has to put on his big-boy pants, swing for the fences and make solid contact. He has a lot more to work with than some seem to think. But he can’t be content to make a few tweaks. Just hope Mario stays the hell out of the way.

  4. James Sciortino

    May 26, 2019 at 1:32 am

    You have already seen the expected return, a less talented winger with more defensive edge.

    Maatta might bring better return than Kessel

  5. David

    May 30, 2019 at 6:22 pm

    Two points: First, these commentators might be high on Kessel. But are the other teams in the league ringing GMJR’s phone off the hook? Apparently not. Why not? What do they know? Secondly, I cannot believe that the Pens organization would be so stupid to trade a point per game guy unless he is a major problem. GMJR isn’t going to do that without support from Sulivan at least.

Make your voice heard

%d bloggers like this:

Join PHN Extra!

Join PHN+ today for exclusive content from Dan and Shelly plus a completely Google ad-free experience.


Or enter your email below to sign-up for our mailing list.

Thank you!

Something went wrong.

No thanks. I don't want.

Send this to a friend