Connect with us


Kingerski: Penguins Firing Mike Sullivan is Silly Suggestion



Mike Sullivan Pittsburgh Penguins
PHILADELPHIA, PA - APRIL 18: Pittsburgh Penguins Head Coach Mike Sullivan answers questions during an interview after the First Round Stanley Cup Playoff game between the Pittsburgh Penguins and Philadelphia Flyers on April 18, 2018 at Wells Fargo Center in Philadelphia, PA. (Photo by Kyle Ross/Icon Sportswire)

It’s not 1985, and NHL coaches are no longer babysitters who use intermissions for a cigarette break while their star players decide how to play the next period. No longer do NHL coaches toss a bucket of pucks on the ice for the morning skate and return to their office. It’s nearly 2019, and NHL coaches are more important than they’ve ever been. And Pittsburgh Penguins head coach Mike Sullivan is as good as there is.

When things don’t go well, everyone is smart. Changes are easy to suggest. Jobs are easy to call for. But the reality of those calling for Mike Sullivan’s job is no reality at all. It’s emotional reaction wrapped in a bit of silliness.

It’s understandable to be upset or anxious with the Penguins. They were supposed to have one or two more great runs left in them. Another moment in the sun has turned into a search for answers. And the gut reaction answer is always to look to the coach.

At this point in a column, quotes and locker room reaction would be inserted. However, in this instance, there won’t be supporting quotes from players or the organization. Because it would be impossible to even ask the question and maintain credibility. Even Sidney Crosby, who is more generous with his time and with bad questions than anyone in the league, might flash a derisive side eye before giving a polite answer.

But it was Matt Cullen who told PHN in 2017, “(Sullivan) is probably the best X’s and O’s coach I’ve been around.”

Before the inexplicable performance in Chicago, the Penguins were 6-2-2 in their last 10. And perhaps Penguins fans who firmly believe a new head coach would right the ship should ask Chicago about firing a good coach. The Chicago Blackhawks were 3-12-2 since firing Joel Quenneville. Now, they’re a whopping 4-12-2.

You may also ask Los Angeles and St. Louis how their “Fire the head coach!” strategy worked out.

It is with some irony, the most derided coaching change–Ken Hitchcock in Edmonton–has been the most successful. Hitchcock has worked in the land just south of the Arctic Circle because he’s also a very good coach and brought a new, appropriate style of play to the team. The defensive stalwart coach is preaching Corsi hockey. My how times change.

The Penguins have aging, mistake-prone players who are still capable of extraordinary things but those mistakes are growing. Not Quenneville or Scotty Bowman or Al Abour could fix those problems.

The Penguins issues have been a carousel of old and new issues, but rarely the same thing twice–because the coaches have done a good job of adjusting. Sullivan, in his fourth season with the Penguins, has been more like a street performer racing to keep the plates spinning, or if you prefer, the little Dutch boy plugging his fingers in the leaky wall.

Perhaps Sullivan should set up tables in the locker room just to flip them?

The Penguins PK hit a rough patch. Fixed. The PK is now in the top-10.

Penguins franchise goaltender struggled and cost the Penguins games. Sullivan had the courage to put in a 27-year-old backup who only had 14 games of NHL experience. The move worked. Casey DeSmith is 9-5-4.

Many of those who may argue, “bring in a new voice,” are still stewing over Daniel Sprong, yet rarely credit the coach for inserting inexperienced players like DeSmith, Dominik Simon, Zach Aston-Reese, and Juuso Riikola.

Would a new coach be able to get Evgeni Malkin and Phil Kessel to play their best games every night? Would God him (or her)self be able to so? Perhaps some should remember the Dan Bylsma era and Mike Johnston era, or the end of the Michael Therrien era.

The Penguins coaches are tactically on top of their game with in-game adjustments and fitting their approach to the personnel. The breakouts have evolved this season. The scheme and offensive approaches have also evolved with the team.

Every head coach makes mistakes or has “his” players. Every single coach. No, I never understood the Ian Cole beef either but until Sullivan has such issues with a guy who wears No. 87, the Penguins will be fine.

The Penguins have flaws and it will a lot more fun to dissect and discuss those than it will be sifting through layers of silliness first.

Subscribe to PHN+

Pittsburgh Hockey Now Editor-in-Chief, formerly 93.7 The Fan, Sportsnet Hockey Tonight, NHL Home Ice. Catch Dan tweeting @theDanKingerski and the official @pghhockeynow account.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
3 years ago

Agree with everything you wrote except the franchise goalie costing the team games. 58 and 71 has caused the Pens to lose games. Other Pens as well. 30 has struggled certainly. 30 also played behind many defensive efforts similar to the most recent game vs Chicago where DeSmith battled to the end. If 30 would have played in that game with exact result and same end, I think the issue would have been 30 really struggled again. No doubt 30 needs to raise his game though and he hasn’t performed as expected. The team D is the biggest problem IMO… Read more »

James from Florida
James from Florida
3 years ago
Reply to  Ricardo58

I agree 58 and 71 at times really just lose focus and it has cost the Pens dearly.

Also I believe this is Murrays last stand if if continues to flop he is in trouble.

3 years ago

Eh, WTH…let’s fire Sullivan, Rutherford, Crosby, Letang, Murray, Johnson, Maatta, Pearson, Simon, and why not ZAR too just b/c he’s not Sprong. Then we’ll make Kessel the head coach and GM. The team will practice if they feel like, play if they feel like it, shoot if they feel like it, and only once or twice a year back-check. Lines will be Kessel and Malkin. All four lines. That will make everyone happy.

Join PHN Extra!

Join PHN+ today for exclusive content from Dan, Dave and Shelly plus a completely Google ad-free experience.


Or enter your email below to sign-up for our mailing list.

Thank you!

Something went wrong.

No thanks. I don't want.