Connect with us


The Dangers of Penguins Winning with ‘Not our Best,’ Sullivan is On It



Pittsburgh Penguins, Mike Sullivan

“I don’t know. That’s a good question,” Pittsburgh Penguins winger Bryan Rust conceded on Tuesday night after his team again played an incomplete or inconsistent game but earned two points.

Is there a danger to winning and consistently being rewarded for less than their best? Which is more critical at this point in the season, the process or result?

The Penguins have won 17 of 19 games, but the back half of the stretch has not resembled the crisp, passionate hockey that led to a 10-game winning streak before the Penguins embarked on a six-game road trip through Philadelphia and the Western Conference. The team was 4-2-0 on the trip, but the level of hockey declined.

“We know it’s not our best hockey,” Jeff Carter said last week.

A week later, the Penguins haven’t lost, but they’re still not playing their best hockey, either. The Penguins beat the Winnipeg Jets despite being outplayed for most of the game. They scored two goals in nine seconds, then won in a shootout. The Penguins trailed Columbus on Friday night before a comeback win and trailed the Vegas Golden Knights 3-0 before a furious late rally netted two points.

Pittsburgh Penguins Past

More than a few teams have been rolled through the regular season, stacking wins, and were returned to sender when the playoffs began. The President’s Trophy curse isn’t so much a curse but a realization that winning in the regular season is different than wining under the bright lights and intensity of the NHL playoffs.

The Tampa Bay Lightning stumbled through the 2019 regular season with wins on top of wins. The scrappy Columbus Blue Jackets sent them home in four games.

The Pittsburgh Penguins maturity bled through the answers.

“Maybe a little bit, but I think everybody involved from the coaching staff on down knows that it’s not our best and it’s not going to cut it down the line. But I think it shows something good for our group that we can find ways to win those games. I think we just can’t get too big of a head about it,” Rust said.

Great shot, kid. Don’t get cocky.

In fairness, Rust’s answer surprised me just a little. It was perfect, actually.

“And we’ve got to look at games realistically and say, ‘Hey, this wasn’t our best. This isn’t how you do it,’ but good marks on us for winning the game,” concluded Rust. “I think that’s been the message here over the past few games that we’ve won that maybe we didn’t have our best. I think that will continue to be the message if we don’t play good for 60 minutes or play the way that we want to play.”

The 2019 Penguins also fall under that category as they stumbled through wins down the stretch and were home in four games. Perhaps a few other Penguins teams in the Sidney Crosby era fit the bill, too. The Dan Bylsma Penguins era had a few teams with lots of regular-season wins, which otherwise laid an egg in the postseason. 

They believed they would keep winning, but their flaws were exposed, and the regular-season winning, coupled with past success, perhaps inoculated the Penguins against genuinely improving.

PHN also put the question to head coach Mike Sullivan. Is there a danger to winning, thus being rewarded for “not (their) best” hockey? Is it an invitation for bad habits to take root?

“There can be. If you don’t have a realistic assessment of where your team is at, and that’s part of our responsibility as the coaching staff–to make sure we see things objectively. We have honest conversations with our players on what our expectations are of ourselves. We talk a lot about the standard and what it means to be a Pittsburgh Penguin and living up to those expectations every day,” Sullivan said.

Winning can cover a lot of warts. It was interesting to hear an NHL head coach acknowledge winning could be a problem and that it was his job to pop a few balloons, figuratively speaking.

And Rust was on the same page.

And yes, this discussion is incomplete without indirectly tying the Penguins’ sloppy play to the return of Evgeni Malkin, which occurred on the west coast trip. The Penguins haven’t been the same, but they’re also able to out-talent teams while they figure it out, too.

Malkin had one shot and two points on Tuesday night. He has nine points (3-6-9) in eight games.

The Penguins aren’t playing anything close to their best hockey, but they now trail the New York Rangers by one point with a game in hand for the top spot in the Metro Division and trail the Florida Panthers by four points for the President’s Trophy.

Maybe the correct answer is that it’s better to win the games but acknowledge the shortcomings rather than lose. It’s a tight rope to walk. A loss or two more easily provides the right motivation to fix the problems.

Lest the players begin to believe their own press or be happy with the win, Mike Sullivan is on it.

Subscribe to PHN+

Pittsburgh Hockey Now Editor-in-Chief, formerly 93.7 The Fan, Sportsnet Hockey Tonight, NHL Home Ice. Catch Dan tweeting @theDanKingerski and the official @pghhockeynow account.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
8 months ago

Happy for the Pens but a good gauge will be when we start playing the Canes, Bruins, Rangers, and the Islanders

8 months ago

Skill players like Crosby/Letang have elevated since Malkin’s return, other players like MP seem to really struggle when game loosens up. As a fan you can’t help but feel “this is the night it gets away from them.” But then they power right thru your pessimism and next thing you know McGinn is going backhand then Boyle is elevating a puck thru his legs to cap an exhilarating 6-3 win. Will it work in June? Who knows? Sure makes the long nights in January more entertaining.

8 months ago
Reply to  Dan Kingerski

Wow Dan you must not sleep if you are drinking coffee during night games! I can’t even do that and I live in Rocky Mountains. That is unless you mean “coffee” as in some other type of harder concoction in which case I’m right there with you thru the rollercoaster…

8 months ago

“Be realistic” is appropriate. But we should be consistently realistic.

If sloppy play can be traced to (as in caused by) Malkin’s return), and you want to make a case that the Pens’ great play prior to that was due to an amazing coaching job, then you have to lay the blame for poor play on the coach as well.

One player doesn’t play every shift. If one guy coming back causes the entire team to get sloppy then the guy who bears the most blame is the head coach.


[…] Pittsburgh Penguins head coach Mike Sullivan continues to be a strong candidate for the Jack Adams award. (Pittsburgh Hockey Now) […]

8 months ago

You are not blaming Malkin but I am… I said just before he came back that the team as a whole would not play as good as they were without him and I was right. His lack of attention to details, his bonehead turnovers and how he often looks completely desinterested and indifferent have clearly an impact on the way some of his teammates are now playing…..

Jeff Young
Jeff Young
8 months ago
Reply to  teamquebec

I agree. It seems each time Malkin returns, there’s an “adjustment” period. Is there ever one when Sid’s out and he returns? If so, is it as big of an issue as Geno’s? Heck, even when Geno has played a ton of games without interruptions you always seem to get those turnovers and bad penalties. And I always wonder why you do.