Connect with us


Possible Penguins Lines and Battles vs. Montreal Canadiens



Pittsburgh Penguins Jason Zucker

Projecting the Pittsburgh Penguins lines is now, unfortunately, easier without Nick Bjugstad, who had spinal surgery at the Mayo Clinic in Minnesota on Tuesday. We won’t know if Penguins head coach Mike Sullivan would have put Jared McCann in the middle or Bjugstad on the third line.

There are more battles and decisions ahead for Sullivan, but now those decisions shift to finding the player who has his legs or rhythm beside the established players.

Always keep in mind Sullivan likes to build pairs and shuffle the third member. So, Conor Sheary may appear on the top line, but will not last if he isn’t on top of his game. We expect Sullivan to pair Jake Guentzel with Sidney Crosby and Bryan Rust to Evgeni Malkin in the NHL playoffs.

Sullivan kept the fourth line together for most of the season, so that seems to have some permanence. The rest may be fluid.


The biggest battle remaining will be if Evan Rodrigues can force his way into the Penguins lineup. The forward whom the Penguins acquired with Conor Sheary from Buffalo at the NHL trade deadline has only 10 points (6g, 4a) in 45 games this season. He has just one goal in seven games with the Penguins and served as a healthy scratch against the Washington Capitals on March 7.

Rodrigues played very well in the two games following the press box experience. He scored his first Penguins goal in the final game before the NHL season pause. The righty could slot on Crosby’s right wing or down the lineup if Sullivan elevates Patric Hornqvist or Bryan Rust.

Sheary has the weakest foothold in the lineup. Should he or the Penguins top line not look cohesive, he could be the first (and quickest) change.

Sam Lafferty nor Anthony Angello will supplant any of the Penguins top four centers, but Lafferty will be the first out of the press box if the Penguins need to replace a left winger.

As part of the NHL playoffs and return to play plan, the league expanded rosters to 28 skaters. None of the projected Penguins “Black Aces” including Adam Johnson or Phil Varone are immediate threats to crack the Penguins lines. Still, if the Penguins do suffer an injury or multiple injuries, perhaps 2019 first round pick Sam Poulin could jump into the lineup if the Penguins need to fill a “skill” role.

If the Penguins select Poulin for the expanded roster, his Phase 3 training camp performance will dictate his position. It is far from a guarantee that he receives the call.

The Penguins do not have any battles on the blue line. Spare defensemen Juuso Riikola and Chad Ruhwedel are comfortable as the Penguins seventh and eighth defensemen.

Pittsburgh Penguins Lines

Guentzel – Crosby – Sheary

Zucker – Malkin – Rust

Marleau – McCann – Hornqvist

Aston-Reese — Blueger — Tanev

Penguins Defense Pairs and Goalie

Dumoulin – Letang

Pettersson – Marino

Johnson – Schultz

Matt Murray

Muray is the unquestioned starter as the NHL begins preparations to move to Phase 2 sometime next week. We’re in uncharted territory in the NHL playoffs Return to Play Plan, so no one is quite sure how it will affect goalies. Murray has struggled with health and consistency in the first half of each of the past three seasons.

In January, the Penguins coaches privately laid out the goalie rotation with Murray scheduled for the big games. However, coaches were quick to caution both goalies that the situation would change based on performance.

Subscribe to PHN+

Pittsburgh Hockey Now Editor-in-Chief, formerly 93.7 The Fan, Sportsnet Hockey Tonight, NHL Home Ice. Catch Dan tweeting @theDanKingerski and the official @pghhockeynow account.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Igbpv Vla
Igbpv Vla
2 years ago

I would switch Zucker and Marleau just to add more scoring throughout and zucker is a perfect third line guy on our team

Simon Hargus
Simon Hargus
2 years ago

i was more impressed with Rod than Sheary but 1st line impressed, no. But Sheary doesn’t belong there either. I miss Simon! i Crosby has his shooter back. I’d put Horny on crosby right wing and sheary on 3rd line. Horny will use that screen skillz to let pucks get past price.

2 years ago

Simon, Sheary doesn’t get a spot in the lineup unless it’s with Sid and the only guys I see on Sids wings at this point are a combo of Zucker, Jake and Sheary, Malkin will most likely get a combo of Rust, Horny, Jake, Marleau, Zucker and the rest will be filtered down, if Sheary isn’t with Sid he’ll very quickly be replaced with ERod in the lineup if not right away.

Eric Bouchard
Eric Bouchard
2 years ago

I always heated SHeary on the top 2 lines. But they dont have any choix right now. I wonder if Sully would put Guentzel back with Sid or Geno. Guentzel could also play rw on Sid’s line One guy who could make a difference is McCaan. Hope he can step up. Would love to see him play on the next level. It could mean a new contract in the next off season. Bjugstad and Shultz are done in the Pens jersey im pretty sure….. Murray too is playing for a new contract but for the #1 one spot next year.… Read more »

2 years ago

Never thought I would say this about this player since he’s been non existent for an entire season but the Bjugstad injury actually hurts in icing the best potential lineup as it forces McCann into the 3rd line center role with the chances of him going to the wing now almost non existent due to the large drop off in talent from McCann as line 3 C to his replacement (assume ERod). Could have given us a top 6 of Jake Sid Zucker/McCann Rust Geno McCann/Zucker which would have been able to rival any top 6 in the league and… Read more »

Join PHN Extra!

Join PHN+ today for exclusive content from Dan, Dave and Shelly plus a completely Google ad-free experience.


Or enter your email below to sign-up for our mailing list.

Thank you!

Something went wrong.

No thanks. I don't want.