Connect with us


What Exactly is Jim Rutherford’s Trade Deadline Plan B?



“With the way the lines are spread out now, and the scoring spread out, we may be able to do this a little different way.”– Jim Rutherford

What is the “different way?”

Last Wednesday, the Penguins’ General Manager told the Cook and Poni radio show on 93.7 The Fan the Penguins are considering abandoning their chase of a third-line center in favor of middle depth. After seven months, and after couple deals which fell apart in the final minutes, the Penguins are looking at other ways “to do this.”

“This” of course means to build a Stanley Cup-worthy team around Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin.

However, the initial stated premise by Rutherford, that scoring has been spread out across several lines, is a mirage. The Penguins are not a four-line team. They are a two-center team.

The third line produces points when Sidney Crosby is the center between Jake Guentzel and Phil Kessel. The fourth line produces when Crosby or Malkin pivot between Tom Kuhnhackl and Bryan Rust.

Tuesday, the Penguins showed offensive flair and relentless spirit against the Vegas Golden Knights. After Carter Rowney was injured in the first period, Crosby played over 25 minutes including time on the penalty killing unit. Malkin skated for over 21 minutes.

Head coach Mike Sullivan loaded up the top lines; Guentzel with Crosby, and Kessel with Malkin. The results were as dynamic as the players involved.

Circumstance forced the Penguins hand Tuesday. However, the Penguins coaches have employed similar strategies for the past six weeks.

The results have been evident, but with a downside. The Penguins are winning, their best players are producing, and their secondary players are often spectators who drive Crosby’s ice time to its highest level in four years.

Load up the top six?

If the Penguins cannot find or acquire the proper pivot, the “other way” is old school Penguins thinking: Load up the top six.

If you can’t roll four good lines, roll two great ones. Everything which is old becomes new again.

The Penguins scouts have attended Buffalo Sabres games and Montreal Canadiens games. Both the Sabres and Canadiens have coveted left wingers who would be a significant upgrade over Dominik Simon on the Penguins top line.

The Sabres are still shopping pending unrestricted free agent Evander Kane. Kane, a power forward, had trouble previously in the Jets’ locker room and had a brush with the law in June 2016. He has just one point (0g, 1a) in his last 13 games.

The price tag, at last rumor in mid-January, was a first-round pick, a prospect, and a conditional draft pick. Of course, that sticker price was before Kane went colder than the city of Buffalo. Kane, who is owed about $1.7 million through the end of the season, would be the first power forward in a Penguins sweater since the last time they tried to stack the top line–the 2013 Jarome Iginla debacle.

The other brand name left wing supposedly on the market is the Canadiens’ Max Pacioretty. The Montreal captain has not sunk with the ship. Pacioretty, 29, has 13 points (8g, 5a) in his last 14 games.

Last weekend, Sportsnet’s Nick Kypreos asserted it would take four pieces to get Pacioretty, or a solid NHL player and a piece in return. Pacioretty is owed almost $1.5 million this season and has a cap friendly $4.5 million hit next season.

Rick and the Rangers … Or Someone Else?

It’s almost silly to think the Rangers and Penguins could make a high profile trade but if the Rangers are truly bowing out of the playoff chase, it is in theory possible.

However, Nash’s high salary (he’s owed $2.5 this season), his pending unrestricted free agency, and the Rangers reportedly ridiculous asking price make this seem like a possibility only on a video game.

Nash’s teammate, Michael Grabner is also up for grabs. Grabner is a pending unrestricted free agent on an absurdly affordable contract. Grabner is owed about $532,000, has elite speed and has rediscovered his scoring touch.

Grabner would allow the Penguins to create three potent lines with speed. Grabner has 21 goals this season.

Injuries Make Prices Go Up

The Penguins biggest problem is again injuries. Wingers Patric Hornqvist and Conor Sheary are out for a few more weeks. Kuhnhackl and Rowney could be out, as well.

Perhaps it was a coincidence the L.A. Kings and Winnipeg Jets immediately stopped scouting the Penguins following Sheary’s injury (stick tap to Twitter follower Tom McCarthy for pointing that out).

If opposing GMs were trying to hold Rutherford to a higher standard before, now their ask will feel like armed robbery. The league knows the Penguins are simultaneously chasing history and have only a few more chances at a Stanley Cup. The championship window is wide open but closing.

The Penguins need for reinforcements could be urgent by tomorrow, which only makes the prices higher.

Get ready for an overpayment for depth replacements or a big splash. Daniel Sprong, a first-round pick, and Sheary are fair game. Do not exclude Guentzel from the list of potential trade chips, either. That’s the cost of doing business this season.

For the Penguins to win another Stanley Cup, they will have to lose a trade. Or two. There just isn’t another way to win, this season.

Plan B may be to add big name talent for the top six. But Plan A, a solid third-line center, would still be the shortest route to sustainability.

Subscribe to PHN+

Pittsburgh Hockey Now Editor-in-Chief, formerly 93.7 The Fan, Sportsnet Hockey Tonight, NHL Home Ice. Catch Dan tweeting @theDanKingerski and the official @pghhockeynow account.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Praveen R
Praveen R
4 years ago

Sheahan is a decent 3C if you give him goal scoring wingers. What we need is a better 4C who can win faceoffs at a high rate. That will ease the burden on Crosby and Malkin. Sheahan is doing decently at faceoffs. I still think if Cole is good as a rental to someone, that someone is the Pens and it wouldnt be a bad idea to actually keep Cole since he offers a skill that complements the rest of the team. You won’t get equal value for Letang. So he is off the table. Maybe Sheary and Dumoulin for… Read more »

4 years ago

I would trade 4 Kane soon. Buffalo has really disappointed this season. Heard similar junk about Kessel before he arrived in PGH. Has been a solid contributor to 2 straight Cups. Maybe a third. Letang would be the guy to trade. Can’t hit an elephant sized net and need cap relief. Reaves was excellent vs. Vegas. Hope he plays like that rest of season and in the playoffs.

4 years ago
Reply to  John

Thing is…the Pens really don’t need any cap relief. Plus, I wouldn’t move Letang unless the return was huge and immediate. That’s just not going to happen right now.

4 years ago

I am offering nothing that isn’t already known, but playoff hockey is typically not like last night’s wide open game. The team that can grind along with tight checking and then take advantage of offensive opportunities will usually win. 72 goal vs Nashville in game 6 is one of many examples. To that end, Pacioretty would fit nicely. However, the cost analysis may be too high. As noted above, Kane may fit in well especially with proven players like 87, 71, 81 etc and I believe 75 and Kane are friends off of the ice. As the writer notes, it… Read more »

4 years ago

I would be willing to do Sprong,1st, 2019 2nd, Sheary for Max P… Great value for the cap hit and under contract for next year….

4 years ago
Reply to  Pensarmy

I think that’s too much for patches. Sheary’s a solid roster player that’s signed for 2 more years at 3mil. I don’t give up both Sprong and Sheary for any LW that’s available.

Join PHN Extra!

Join PHN+ today for exclusive content from Dan, Dave and Shelly plus a completely Google ad-free experience.


Or enter your email below to sign-up for our mailing list.

Thank you!

Something went wrong.

No thanks. I don't want.