Connect with us


Notebook: ZAR Feels Difference, Penguins Want Clarity on Marino Helmet Loss



Pittsburgh Penguins Brandon Tanev
Brandon Tanev: Photo Courtesy of Pittsburgh Penguins

Cal Clutterbuck was wide open near the Pittsburgh Penguins crease and buried the first of two New York Islanders’ goals early in the third period. It wasn’t a defensive breakdown that left Clutterbuck wide open but a lost lid that allowed the Islanders fourth-liner to bury a rebound chance.

New York put the Penguins on their heels, and a defeat seemed likely as defenseman John Marino’s helmet spun on the ice like the Penguins’ heads were spinning on the bench. Per NHL rules, a player cannot continue to play without a helmet, and Marino’s was knocked off during a puck battle in the corner.

Whether or not Marino’s helmet was knocked off intentionally will be a matter of debate, as will Marino’s ability to stay in the play.

“We’re actually asking for a little bit more clarity in that circumstance because it’s our understanding that John can stay in the battle there,” Penguins head coach Mike Sullivan said on Friday. “Obviously, we get outnumbered because of it. So we’re actually asking for clarity on that from the league because it’s my understanding that he can stay in that battle and look for the opportune time to get to the bench.”

After his helmet fell to the ice, Marino skated towards it but couldn’t pick it up on the first pass. On video replay, he hesitated before racing for the bench.

The second-year pro was visibly angry on the bench after Clutterbuck, who would have been Marino’s responsibility, scored.

Defenseman Cody Ceci, who changed for Marino, could not get into the play in time. The goal halved the Penguins’ lead to 3-2 and launched New York’s comeback.

The NHL instituted the rule beginning with the 2019-20 season. It also states, “shall be given a reasonable opportunity to complete the play,” but Marino was on the edge of scrum and wasn’t technically making a play on the puck.

Also, should a player internationally knock another player’s helmet off, it is a roughing penalty by rule. When it leads to a goal:

That would have made the game interesting.

Pittsburgh Penguins 4th Line/ Zach Aston-Reese:

The Pittsburgh Penguins fourth line began and ended the scoring on Thursday night. The output continued the Penguins fourth line prominence, which has thus far kept the Islanders’ top liners Mathew Barzal and Jordan Eberle from scoring a goal.

The trio centered by Teddy Blueger, which Zach Aston-Reese on the left and Brandon Tanev on the right, has been a secret weapon since Sullivan united them early last season. Both Tanev and Aston-Reese received Selke award votes last season.

However, while a handful of Penguins have Stanley Cup rings, Aston-Reese arrived a year too late. The winger didn’t make his NHL debut until late in the 2017-18 season. Since then, the Penguins have won only one playoff series.

Aston-Reese was originally credited with the game’s first goal, but scorers later changed it to Kris Letang.

“I could have zero points and be completely happy as long as we’re winning. You know, it’s so much fun winning in playoffs,” Aston-Reese said. “I’ve had a lot of playoff experience…that previous experience kind of not doing so well stinks. So just to have team success…the last two games has been feeling really good.”

Aston-Reese has one assist in three playoff games this season. He had one assist in four games last season and three career assists in 20 playoff games. Had the original scoring stuck, it would have been Aston-Reese’s first playoff goal.

The Penguins win on Thursday night gave the team their first series lead since they won Game 1 of their Round Two matchup against the Washington Capitals in 2018. In fact, the Penguins have won only two playoff games since then.

For Aston-Reese, the difference in feeling is something to enjoy, and it’s the first time the Penguins have won a second game in any series since 2018.

On Thursday night, PHN asked Sullivan about the atmosphere and conversations on the Penguins bench when New York turned the game into a battle royal. Aston-Reese further described the scene on Friday.

“Right off the top of my head, it just comes to (Brandon) Tanev. I know he was the first guy to start being vocal. He was telling the boys ‘just relax, calm down. Play a simple game.’ We’ve got to get pucks north and get in on the forecheck,” Aston-Reese said. “(Kris Letang), too, said force them to defend…it’s just a crazy atmosphere, and we’ve got to play the right way to drown out the crowd and limit the Islanders.”

Subscribe to PHN+

Pittsburgh Hockey Now Editor-in-Chief, formerly 93.7 The Fan, Sportsnet Hockey Tonight, NHL Home Ice. Catch Dan tweeting @theDanKingerski and the official @pghhockeynow account.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
David Heyl
David Heyl(@belfairroxi)
7 months ago

I only saw Penguins getting helmets torn off, possible strategy to slow them down. The Marino play was a joke.

7 months ago

I agree, Dan, it should be a reviewable play… and it needs to be clarified what it means by “a reasonable opportunity to complete the play” as not all plays involve handling the puck. 

7 months ago
Reply to  Tony

I absolutely should not be reviewable! You can’t determine intent by review. Let’s not become the NFL . Strap them on tighter and let the players play.

7 months ago
Reply to  Dan Kingerski

If your helmet comes off because of an opposing players hand the intentionality is completely irrelevant.

They could even add “a distinct grabbing motion” to follow suit on previous rules.

Stephen Powanda
Stephen Powanda(@pozone)
7 months ago

The last 2 games the Pens have played excellent playoff hockey Games. Jeff Carter the steal of the year. Great job Hexy.

7 months ago

You have to wonder if the Refs said something to Marino as his first instinct was to stay.

7 months ago

Pasternak lost his helmet in last nights game. Picked it up put it back on and remained in the play.

Dave Davies
Dave Davies
7 months ago

If the league continues to allow it then players are going to begin to take advantage of it. I think that the Islanders were already doing that in that game on Thursday. You can argue that Marinos helmet was knocked off unintentionally, but it seemed intentional to me. It’s also hard to give Islanders players the benefit of the doubt when their coach has them playing as close to the line as they possibly can without getting penalized. What bothers me is that the league wouldn’t allow 10% of the bullshit that they allow in the playoffs to go on… Read more »

Join PHN Extra!

Join PHN+ today for exclusive content from Dan and Shelly plus a completely Google ad-free experience.


Or enter your email below to sign-up for our mailing list.

Thank you!

Something went wrong.

No thanks. I don't want.